Data Strategy Best Practices for Nonprofits: Your Roadmap to Growth and Efficiency

Angie oversees Cazoomi's operations. She enjoys traveling, loves dogs, is a 1% Pledge supporter, and a start-up entrepreneur with investments in several APAC startups. 14 minute read

Data Strategy Best Practices for Nonprofits: Everything You Need to Know

Can you think of a more valuable asset today than data? Other than money, of course. We can’t!

Since we’ve been working closely with nonprofits for two decades, we know that they rarely leverage their data to the fullest. So today, we’re exploring data strategy best practices for nonprofits.

Did you know that 78% of nonprofits don’t have a data strategy? Worse yet, 56% of nonprofits say they lack the tools needed to analyze data effectively.

We understand this better than you know. 12% of nonprofits can’t make it past their fifth year, and 30% of them don’t make it to 10 years because of insufficient funding. 

This happens even though nonprofits hire more than 10% of the US workforce.

At a glance, the nonprofit industry looks promising. However, if you’re a small nonprofit, chances are you will struggle, no matter how big the issue you are solving is.

Nonprofits employ 10 percent of USA workforce

Let’s end the nonprofit starvation cycle together.

Starting with data strategy best practices for nonprofits that don’t cost an arm and a leg!

But first, a quick primer:

Why You Need a Data Strategy for Your Nonprofit

A solid data strategy provides the framework for how your organization will collect, manage, analyze, and use data to meet your objectives. 

It allows nonprofits to make better, data-driven decisions that can significantly impact their ability to fulfill their mission. Whether it’s optimizing fundraising campaigns, improving donor retention, or measuring program effectiveness, data plays a critical role in a nonprofit’s success.

The Growing Importance of Data in the Nonprofit Sector

Nonprofits are increasingly being judged not just on their mission, but on their impact. Funders, donors, and stakeholders now demand transparency, measurable outcomes, and accountability. GuideStar highlights that donors are increasingly scrutinizing transparency, data, and impact reports before contributing.

Without an effective data strategy, nonprofits struggle to provide this kind of visibility and risk losing out on crucial funding.

Core Benefits of a Data Strategy for Nonprofits

  1. Enhanced decision-making: a well-executed data strategy allows you to use data to guide strategic decisions, leading to more efficient and impactful operations.
  2. Donor retention and engagement: by analyzing donor behavior, nonprofits can improve engagement strategies, personalize outreach efforts, and maintain strong relationships with their supporters.
  3. Operational efficiency: with accurate data, nonprofits can track the effectiveness of their programs, allocate resources more strategically, and reduce administrative overhead.
  4. Compliance and transparency: accurate data helps nonprofits comply with regulations and maintain transparency with stakeholders, which is essential for reputation management and fundraising.

Common Data Challenges Nonprofits Face (And How to Overcome Them)

While a solid data strategy is crucial for nonprofit success, it’s not without its challenges. Many nonprofits, especially smaller ones, encounter obstacles when implementing and maintaining a data-driven approach.

Let’s explore some of the most common data challenges nonprofits face and practical ways to address them.

Limited Resources and Expertise

Nonprofits often operate with limited budgets and small teams, which can make it difficult to invest in sophisticated data management tools or hire dedicated data experts. 

Solution: start small and prioritize. Focus on collecting and analyzing only the most important data types that directly impact your goals. Additionally, use cost-effective tools like SyncApps to integrate data across platforms without the need for a large IT team. 

Like SyncApps, many other software providers offer discounted or free versions of their tools for nonprofits, allowing even small organizations to adopt powerful data management systems.

Data Silos

Data silos occur when different departments within a nonprofit use separate systems that don’t communicate with each other. This can lead to fragmented data and a lack of transparency across the organization. 

For example, the marketing team might use an email marketing tool to track campaign success, while the fundraising team uses a different system to track donor interactions. Without integration, it’s difficult to get a complete view of donor engagement and program effectiveness.

Solution: Break down silos by integrating systems. Use tools like SyncApps to connect your CRM, marketing automation, and financial software so that all data flows seamlessly between platforms. 

Data Quality Issues

Poor data quality is a common problem for nonprofits, leading to inaccurate reports, inefficient operations, and missed opportunities. 

Plus, you pay for each contact you have, whether it’s a higher subscription fee to your CRM or higher postage fees if you send regular mail. Why not make sure your data is clean?

Solution: Implement data cleaning protocols and regular audits to ensure the accuracy of your data. Encourage staff to follow consistent data entry practices, and consider using software that can automatically detect and merge duplicate records. 

Many CRMs, including Salesforce, offer built-in tools for data cleaning and validation.

Data Security and Privacy Concerns

Nonprofits handle sensitive data, including donor information, financial records, and program participant details. A breach of this data can damage your organization’s reputation and lead to legal consequences. 

NTEN found multiple problems with nonprofit data, including how it’s stored and shared (or not shared) among nonprofits.

Solution: Invest in secure cloud-based data management systems that offer encryption and other security features. Ensure that your organization complies with data privacy laws such as GDPR and CCPA, and train staff on best practices for data security. Regularly update your security protocols and use password management tools to protect sensitive information.

Practical Data Strategy Tips for Your Nonprofit

Given the resource constraints many nonprofits face, developing and implementing a data strategy can seem like an overwhelming task. 

However, with the right approach and tools, even small nonprofits can build a successful data strategy that maximizes the value of the data they collect.

There is a huge push for nonprofits to go more digital — and many of them have already done it. Let’s see how you can join them without spending a fortune on your data strategy and its implementation. 

Identify the Most Valuable Data to Collect

One of the first steps in building a data strategy is to identify the types of data that will have the biggest impact on your nonprofit’s mission. Too often, nonprofits collect a lot of data, but not all of it is useful. 

In fact, too much data can harm your operations. So let’s make sure you collect and analyze the right data.

Here are some of the most important data types nonprofits should consider:

  • Donor data: names, addresses, emails, donation amounts, donor frequency, and demographics. 
  • Program data: program-specific data can track participant numbers, outcomes, attendance rates, and feedback. Having access to this data allows nonprofits to measure the impact of their initiatives and adjust their approach to achieve better outcomes.
  • Volunteer data: information such as volunteer hours, areas of expertise, and event participation can help you manage your volunteer base more efficiently. Gathering feedback and data from volunteers can help you spot areas that need improvement — something that a lot of nonprofits ignore as they only focus on donor data.
  • Financial data: accurate financial records and reports are crucial for fundraising, grant applications, and general operations. Integrating financial data with donor data can help nonprofits identify the most cost-effective strategies and improve their return on investment.
  • Marketing data: website traffic, email marketing metrics, and social media engagement data can help nonprofits better target their campaigns and improve outreach. 

Struggling with your marketing data? Level up your campaigns with data-driven insights and avoid costly data silos. Integrate your marketing automation platform (Constant Contact or Mailchimp) and Salesforce NPSP.

Set Clear and Measurable Objectives

Your data strategy should be directly aligned with your organization’s goals. This means setting clear objectives that data collection will support. Common objectives for nonprofits might include:

  • Increasing donor retention by 15% over the next year
  • Doubling online donations in the next campaign cycle
  • Improving program participation by 10% within six months

By having specific goals in place, your data strategy becomes more targeted and actionable. Additionally, measurable objectives give your team a way to assess the success of your data efforts and make adjustments as necessary.

Choose Affordable and Scalable Tools for Data Management

One of the main concerns for nonprofits is the cost associated with implementing sophisticated data management systems. Fortunately, many solutions offer discounted or free tools for nonprofits. 

Here are some key categories of tools to consider:

  • CRM systems: CRMs like Salesforce Nonprofit Success Pack (NPSP), Bloomerang, and DonorPerfect are designed to help nonprofits manage donor relationships, track giving histories, and improve engagement. Salesforce’s NPSP, in particular, is widely used by nonprofits and has a vast ecosystem of tools and apps built around it.
  • Marketing automation tools: Mailchimp and Constant Contact are nonprofit favorites on our platform. Check out our in-depth comparison of Mailchimp and Constant Contact for nonprofits.
  • Integration platforms: CRM and marketing automation data is a goldmine! But if you keep them siloed, you leverage less than 50% of its power. Integrate these two systems on nonprofit-friendly platforms like SyncApps. By the way, you’ll also enjoy a lifetime discount on SyncApps — because we want to support your mission! Start here!

Prioritize Data Integration for a Holistic View of Your Operations

One of the most common data challenges for nonprofits is dealing with data silos—when different departments or systems don’t communicate with each other. For example, donor data might be housed in a CRM, while marketing data is siloed in email marketing tools or social media platforms. 

This lack of integration makes it difficult for nonprofits to get a complete picture of their performance.

Data integration is crucial for nonprofits that want to streamline their operations and maximize their impact. Integration solutions like SyncApps allow nonprofits to connect systems like Salesforce, Mailchimp, NetSuite, and more. 

By syncing marketing, donor, and financial data, nonprofits can gain deeper insights into their organization’s performance and identify opportunities for improvement.

Want to increase your funding through hyper-targeted campaigns that open donor wallets?

Start integrating your critical data with SyncApps!

Foster a Data-Driven Culture

A data strategy is only as effective as the people who use it. To get the most out of your data, it’s crucial to foster a data-driven culture within your organization. This means training staff on how to collect, interpret, and act on data in their day-to-day activities.

Invest in data literacy training for your team. Organizations like DataKind offer pro bono data science services specifically for nonprofits, helping them train staff and volunteers on how to use data to inform decisions.

Encourage collaboration across departments to ensure that everyone has access to the data they need. Make data accessible through dashboards, reports, and regular meetings to ensure the team remains aligned with the organization’s goals.

More importantly, make sure that everyone has access to data. Integration is your safest bet in making sure that your data is not siloed by department.

Monitor and Optimize Your Data Strategy

Once you’ve implemented your data strategy, it’s crucial to continuously monitor its performance and make adjustments as needed. Set up regular intervals (quarterly or semi-annually) to assess whether your data strategy is meeting its objectives. 

Monitoring KPIs (Key Performance Indicators) will help you determine whether your strategy is on track or if there are areas that need improvement.

Some common KPIs for nonprofits include

  • Donor retention rate: the percentage of donors who continue to give over time.
  • Cost Per Acquisition (CPA): the cost to acquire a new donor or volunteer.
  • Donation growth rate: the increase in donations year-over-year.
  • Volunteer retention rate: the percentage of volunteers who return after their initial engagement.
  • Program effectiveness: metrics that measure the success of specific programs, such as attendance, impact, or participant satisfaction.

By regularly reviewing these KPIs, you can identify trends and make data-driven adjustments to their strategy. 

For example, if donor retention rates are lower than expected, you can investigate and implement new engagement strategies, such as personalized emails or outreach campaigns.

The Role of Data Integration in Nonprofit Growth

Personalization is the lifeblood of modern marketing. It can reduce donor acquisition costs by 50% and improve marketing spend by 30%.

The easiest and most accurate way to personalize your communication with donors, stakeholders, and volunteers is data integration.

Here’s why:

Benefits of Data Integration for Nonprofits

  1. 360-degree view of donor profiles: by integrating donor data from various platforms, such as CRM systems, marketing automation tools, and social media, nonprofits can create comprehensive donor profiles. This enables you to understand donor preferences, past interactions, and engagement levels, ultimately allowing for more personalized communication.
  2. Streamlined operations: data integration reduces the need for manual data entry and mitigates the risk of errors. When data flows seamlessly between platforms, nonprofits can save time and resources that would otherwise be spent on administrative tasks.
  3. Better program insights: integrating program data with marketing and fundraising data helps nonprofits understand the full impact of their initiatives. For example, by syncing program participation data with donor engagement information, nonprofits can identify which programs resonate most with supporters and allocate resources accordingly.
  4. Improved fundraising effectiveness: integrated data enables nonprofits to provide a more personalized experience to donors, making them more likely to stay engaged and contribute regularly.
  5. Enhanced reporting and compliance: Nonprofits often face stringent reporting requirements, whether from donors, grantmakers, or regulatory agencies. Integrated data systems simplify reporting by consolidating financial, donor, and program data in one place, making it easier to generate accurate reports.

SyncApps: a Data Integration Solution Tailored for Nonprofits

The easiest way to build the foundation of your nonprofit data strategy is integration. Want to integrate your mission-critical data but don’t know where to start?

That’s why we offer a 28-day, no-obligation trial of SyncApps. We are the preferred integration solution for nonprofits, as proven by our G2 reviews and multiple partnerships with nonprofit advisory companies. 

Here’s why nonprofits love us:

  • 25% discounts for nonprofits forever, not just in the first months.
  • 24/7 support with real humans: you don’t need an in-house tech team; we’ve got you covered.
  • Onboarding call and constant help: beyond support, you can always schedule a call with our consultant to learn how to leverage integration to the fullest.
  • Bidirectional sync for nonprofit integrations: NPSP to Mailchimp or Constant Contact, and others. Let your data flow seamlessly between solutions while you handle strategy, not mundane tasks.

We’ve got dozens of other reasons, but we’ll let you discover them yourself.

Get instant access to data integration here!

As technology continues to evolve, so too will the role of data in the nonprofit sector. Here are some key trends that nonprofits should watch for in the coming years:

Increased Use of AI

AI is already transforming the way nonprofits analyze and use data. AI tools can automate data analysis, provide predictive insights, and even personalize donor outreach based on past behavior.

You can already do all of these things on SyncApps, with and without AI, and we estimate that, in the future, AI will play an ever bigger part in personalization.

Expansion of Data-Driven Storytelling

Nonprofits are increasingly using data to tell compelling stories about their impact. Data visualization tools like Tableau and Google Data Studio make it easier for organizations to present their data in a visually appealing way. 

This trend will continue to grow as more nonprofits realize the power of data-driven storytelling in fundraising and donor engagement.

Growing Importance of Data Ethics

As nonprofits collect more data, they must also consider the ethical implications of how they use and store it. Issues like data privacy, consent, and transparency will become even more important as donors and program participants demand more accountability from organizations. 

Nonprofits will need to adopt strong ethical guidelines for data collection and use.

Conclusion: Data Strategy Best Practices for Nonprofits

“Data strategy” may sound intimidating, especially if you’re already operating on a skeleton crew and with limited resources — as most nonprofits are. Hopefully, this article showed you that data strategy doesn’t have to be too complex or out of reach.

Besides these data strategy best practices for nonprofits, we can help you make the most out of your data. Claim your SyncApps free trial and schedule a call with our consultants. It’s completely free, so what have you got to lose? 



echo do_shortcode('[sc name="exit_promo_popup"]');